An editorial in today's Buffalo News Opinion section is looking for
- A better immigration plan
In order to prove that the person ahead of you in line at the job interview is an illegal immigrant, we are going to have to devise a system that proves that you are not.
That, as much as any bleeding-heart concern for illegals or sweatshop search for cheap workers, has been the barrier to effective reform of an immigration system that really needs it. And New York Sen. Charles E. Schumer is offering a bold step in the right direction by making a fraud-resistant ID system a key part of his plan.
Schumer, a Democrat, and South Carolina Sen. Lindsay Graham, a Republican, have put forward a thoughtful and comprehensive immigration reform plan that deserves the attention of their colleagues, the president and the nation.
In addition to tougher border enforcement, more green cards for educated workers and a stringent path to citizenship for illegals already here, the plan includes what its backers call a “high-tech, fraud-proof Social Security card.” ...
We’ve been fooling around with an alternative, called E-Verify, that is supposed to allow employers to check a central database to see if the Social Security number offered by a new hire matches the government’s records. But it has been shown to be so full of errors, often rejecting people who are clearly native-born citizens, as to be unworkable.
- Time - Ready for Your Biometric Social Security Card?
- The Christian Science Monitor - Immigration reform rests on a national worker ID
- The Dallas Morning News - Wait-and-see is not an immigration policy
- Ruben Navarrette - Graham needs to finish his work on immigration reform
- The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel - Broken, unjust and in dire need of reform
- The Palm Beach Post - Immigration kumbaya: There's a bipartisan opening, really
- The St. Louis Post-Dispatch - Immigration reformers want 'next'
- George F. Will - A birthright? Maybe not
- Froma Harrop - This time, a real immigration fix
-- George Pyle/The Buffalo News