Skip to primary navigation Skip to main content

All-time All-WNY team: How'd we do?

Five all-decade teams, a whole lot of research and feedback, and here it is: the 50th anniversary All-time All-Western New York boys basketball team.

I wrote the story in today's paper after a group of us at the News decided who from the all-decade teams was worthy of the same kind of team we put together every year, and the same kind of team we picked for each decade: 20 players, divided into first, second, third and fourth teams. 

And like with every All-WNY team, and the all-decade teams -- it wasn't easy. And not everyone will agree -- but that's the fun part of debating the best in basketball every season, and for all seasons.

Here are our posts on our all-1960s team, all-1970s team, all-1980s team, all-1990s team and all-2000s team.

Those were preliminary tournaments of a sort. But in picking the all-time team we had no quotas or qualifications. We went with the best players, and the 1970s (seven) and 80s (seven) tied with the most. The other three decades had three all-time selections apiece, all of whom are included in the top 15.

The years listed are the seasons that the player made first team. 

First team
Curtis Aiken, Bennett 1981-82, '82-83
Paul Harris, Niagara Falls, 2003-04, '04-05
Christian Laettner, Nichols 1986-87, '87-88
Bob Lanier, Bennett 1965-66
Mel Montgomery, Kensington 1969-70, '70-71

Second team
Ritchie Campbell, Burgard 1988-89, '89-90
George Carter, Silver Creek 1960-61, '61-62
Mike Russell, East 1973-74
Dwight Williams, Neumann 1974-75
Tim Winn, LaSalle 1993-94, '94-95, '95-96

Third team
Gary Bossert, Kenmore West 1981-82, '82-83
Aaron Curry, Neumann 1975-76
Jonny Flynn, Niagara Falls, 2005-06, '06-07
Jason Rowe, Traditional 1993-94, '94-95, '95-96
Jimmy "Bug" Williams, East 1971-72, '72-73

Fourth team
Ray Hall, McKinley 1979-80, '80-81
Tony Kelly, Lackawanna 1979-80, '80-81, '81-82
Keith Robinson, Grover Cleveland 1984-85, '85-86
Chuck Threeths, Lackawanna 1974-75, '75-76
Rickey Williams, Timon 1973-74

Let the debating begin ...

---Keith McShea


comments powered by Disqus

About Prep Talk

Keith McShea

Keith McShea

Keith McShea has covered high school sports at The News since his hiring in 1999. The 1995 University at Buffalo graduate and Long Island native (North Babylon Bulldogs) covers — and live blogs — everything from scrimmages to state championships & helps head The News' All-Western New York selections.

@KeithMcSheaBN |